N-to-N Two Stage

Home | What's New | Photos | Videos | Projects | Flight Data | Misc Info  | Links

Home

What's New 

Photo Gallery

 

My Best Photos

Coldfire

Angelfire

Starfire

Wildfire

Vulcan

Scorpion

Nike Dart

Tempest

Black Widow

Sentinel

Hybrid Dart

Arcas

Scott's Rockets

The Early Years

Aerial Photos

Tripoli Idaho Photos

LDRS 26  (2007)

     Angelfire at LDRS 26

     Starfire    at LDRS 26

     Wildfire   at LDRS 26

     Scott's Flights at LDRS 26

LDRS 24  (2005)

Desert Heat 2008

Desert Heat 2006

Desert Heat 2005

Summer Skies 2008

Summer Skies 2007

Summer Skies 2006

Summer Skies 2005

Orange Crush Loop

XPRS 2008 Photos

XPRS 2007 Photos

XPRS 2006 Photos

     Starfire    at XPRS 2006

     Angelfire at XPRS 2006

     Wildfire   at XPRS 2006

     Nike Dart at XPRS 2006

XPRS 2005 Photos

XPRS 2004 Photos

FITS 2009 Photos

FITS 2007 Photos

FITS 2006 Photos

FITS 2003 Photos

Vulcan Ignition

Other Photos

Video Gallery

 

Angelfire

Starfire

Wildfire

Vulcan

Scorpion

Other Videos

Video Help          

Projects

 

Coldfire

     Components

     Airframe fiberglassing

     Fin slots

     Motor tube construction

     Fin attachment

     Nitrous vent

     Booster bulkhead

     Fin fillets and finishing

     Nosecone

     Altimeter bay

     Recovery system

     Motor adapter & tailcone

     Decals

     Rail guides

Angelfire

     Booster

     Fin fillets

     Nosecone

     Altimeter bay

     Altimeter electronics

     GPS electronics

     Recovery components

     Painting

     Finishing

Starfire

      Booster

      Fins & motor tubes

      Fin slots

      Body tubes

      Coupler tubes

      Bulkheads

      Mirror hood

      Altimeter bay

      Antizipper band

      Antizipper straps

      Booster Elec-bay

      Camera module

      Camcorder module

      Paint & decals

      Rail guides

Wildfire

Vulcan

Scorpion

Nike Dart

GPS Radio Downlink

Wildfire Camera Module

TV Transmitters

      Transmitter #1

      Transmitter #2

Launch Controller

G-switch Timer

Flight Data

 

Angelfire GPS Trajectories

Angelfire Altimeter Data

Flight Log

Misc Info

 

Altimeters

Altimeter Port Sizing

Altitude Charts

CAD Drawing Software

Centering Rings

Metal Plates

Delay Time Charts

Ejection Charge Sizing

Epoxy

Igniters

Launch Pads

Parachutes (etc)

Rocket Finding

Links

 

General Information

Clubs & Organizations

Rocketry Vendors

Kits and Components

Rocket Motors

Fun & Useful Sites

Electronics

Construction Supplies

Software Tools

Rocketry Magazines

Photographers

NASA

 

 

Photo by Rick Clapp

Adrian Carbine's N-to-N two-stage project 

 

Adrian launched his N-to-N two-stage rocket at XPRS 2005. The flight was flawless except for the fact the main parachute was deployed at apogee.  It reached 40,098 feet and took about a half hour to come down.  It was recovered 5.5 miles away just off the edge of the playa. Some of the paint was scorched or missing but other than that, there was no damage.

Adrian's Commentary

Since people have asked, here are some details about the construction of my N2N project.

 

Dimensions Length: 17 feet, 4 inches
  Sustainer diameter: 4.25 inches
  Booster diameter: 4.6 inches

 

Weights Pad weight: 96.5 lbs 

 

Weight w/o motors:

43.5 lbs 

Including parachutes, tubular nylon, electronics, avionics bays, CO2 systems, etc.  

Off the top of my head, I think the entire airframe weighed something like 25 lbs empty.

 

 

 

 

 

Airframe Construction

 

Sustainer:

CF braid (Aerosleeve) over 4" diameter Hawk Mountain G12 fiberglass tubing.

Booster:

CF braid (Aerosleeve) over 4.5" diameter Performance Rocketry G10 FG tubing.

Note: I liked the PR G10 tubing better (less flex).

 

Fins (3 per stage) are multiple sandwich layers of CF cloth over aircraft plywood, with beveled G10 edges on 3 sides, surface-mounted to the airframe with Kevlar & CF cloth at the joint and large-radius formed fillets reinforced with chopped CF and fiberglass. All fins are reinforced after mounting and filleting with CF cloth and FG cloth, with 5 layers tip-to-tip, rotated strand orientation. They are 1/8" thick at the tip and 3/8" thick at the root where the fillet begins, with airfoil cross-section.

 

All load-bearing separation joints (sustainer drogue at apogee, booster main chute at apogee, and staging separation) use 8"-long same-materials couplers (FG to FG) which are close enough in tolerance to avoid airframe wobble, but with enough clearance to avoid binding under temperature variation. All separation joints were lubricated with graphite lubricant and shear-pinned (as well as vented) to avoid premature separation. All coupler tubes are reinforced internally with CF lamination and aircraft plywood bulkheads.

 

The entire 17-ft airframe is very strong, with very little weight penalty (Aerosleeves CF). I can suspend the 17' airframe horizontally at the booster fins and sustainer nosecone and bounce up and down on it with all my weight: the sustainer flexes slightly, and the booster doesn't flex at all. The fins are completely rigid and do not flex at all, even when I stand on the fin can. All 3 electronics bays slide into their respective body tubes without a joint or break in the body tube, which reduces wobble and improves strength.

 

The airframe is designed for Mach+ flight, using high-temperature materials: fin lamination is done with high-temp epoxy, and the conical Hawk Mountain nose cone has a sharp 5"-long tip which I machined out of aluminum. The paint is another story (see below).

 

 

 

Recovery and Electronics

 

Recovery harnesses are 60 ft long x 1" wide tubular nylon, attached to 1/4" steel U-bolts and 1/2" aircraft plywood bulkheads.

 

Parachutes: the sustainer has a Rocketman drogue and a Skyangle main. The booster uses a single Skyangle main. All chutes are protected by Nomex "burrito" wraps. Here's a good one: the sustainer used a single FG piston for the main. Yes, a piston. :-) The booster main had no reason to use one, nor did the sustainer drogue chute.

 

Deployment: The sustainer uses a Rouse-Tech CO2 system for high-altitude apogee, with dual potted ematches. Main chutes use BP charges (2 gm ea). For deployment electronics, the sustainer uses a Blacksky Altacc2C and an Adept Alts60k, with a Timer2 for a "hail-mary" ballistic re-entry backup charge. The booster uses an Altacc and Timer2 for backup. All deployment systems have full redundancy (batteries, ematches, etc.)

 

Tracking electronics: two BeeLine transmitters, one in each stage.

 

 

 

Staging

 

Staging is active, rather than using drag separation, to allow the rocket to slow down to well below Mach turbulence velocity before attemping separation. I used a Rouse-Tech CO2 system and shear pins, with staging separation initiated from an Adept staging timer in the sustainer, and timer backup in the booster. The CO2 system is located in the forward end of the booster airframe. The staging coupler was lubricated with graphite lubricant.

 

Sustainer motor ignition is controlled by a Blacksky Timer2 in the sustainer. Wiring for separation and ignition runs down the outside of the sustainer airframe, using tape wire laminated into the body tube, and routes through a pair of thin channels passing through the staging coupler. Both staging separation and motor ignition circuits have "pull before flight" shunts on the sustainer. I did several ground tests of the CO2 staging system to make sure that it worked reliably.  For example, I had to upsize the CO2 cartridge to achieve repeatable results.

 

 

 

Motors

 

I used a CTI N2500 in the booster, and an AT N2000 in the sustainer. Motor retention was by bolting each motor to its forward bulkhead and recovery hardware, and each motor also has a snap-ring retainer at the aft end (98mm Slimline)

 

For igniters, I used a couple of Blacksky ematches dipped in Firestar pyrogen, and inserted into small slugs of white lighting propellant. For the booster, the ignitor was held in place by a thin dowel, and on the sustainer, I used a toothpick inserted across the core of the top propellant grain to retain the ignitor wire at the top of the motor.

 

Guidance off the pad was from three Blacksky extreme rail buttons mounted to the booster at airframe hard-points, a couple near the aft end and one at the center of gravity.

 

 

 

Flight Results and Data

 

Booster ignition was rapid, and liftoff from JohnL's A-frame pad at the 1500' away cell was smooth and straight up. Burnout was about a mile up. Staging was perfect: right on time, clean, and straight. It had some drama because most people are used to drag separation, so some watchers thought that something was wrong when it coasted for 4 seconds after booster motor burnout. Sustainer ignition happened a second after separation, and the sustainer just took off. It was hard to tell at that altitude, but the smoke trail of the sustainer looked like there was Mach turbulence, some wind shear at high altitude, and possibly some coning. We saw the booster arcing over and reaching apogee, but we lost sight of the sustainer after the N2000 burn. The BeeLine in the sustainer was still indicating "up", so things looked OK. Finally we spotted the sustainer in the binoculars about 5 minutes later. The only flight anomaly was that the main chute was out at apogee. The sustainer took about a half-hour to fall from apogee to the ground.

 

Alex and Dave found the booster about 1.5 miles out, and brought it back to camp while we were still watching the sustainer come down. The whole gang (GregC, RickC, my friends Randy and Gary, our two boys, and DaveB at the wheel and Alex riding shotgun) piled in the truck and we drove Mad-Max style across the playa, passing Jane, who had followed it until the drift velocity exceeded her vehicle velocity. We finally found the sustainer about 5.5 miles from the pad. The rocket had no damage, except for Mach heating damage to the paint (leading edges of fins, little warts/bubbles on and around wiring fairings, etc.), and the upper body tube had lots a scraping damage to the paint from being dragged around the playa by the chute.

 

The Rocksim simulation predicted 44,000 to 48,000 ft on the two N motors, but actual was 40,098 ft, off the Adept Alts60k. Unfortunately, the Altacc data was garbage, so I don't have the full flight profile for the sustainer. Bummer. I did get good flight data off the Altacc in the booster, and it recorded a booster apogee of 13k ft.

 

 

 

For the Future

 

For construction, I'm making some changes. First of all, I like the Perf Rocketry G10 tubing a lot better, and I want to eliminate some drag (no wiring fairings, better paint (or no paint), smaller staging coupler OD, etc.) and some weight (downsize chutes, less tubular nylon, less body tube lamination, etc.).

 

Motors: for 2-stage flight, I get another mile of altitude by boosting on an N2000 and staging to an N1100. I would also use a spirit level to make sure the rocket was pointing exactly up at liftoff. For XPRS'05, I angled the rocket away from the flight line a bit. I need to figure out the coning thing too.

 

Future record attempts: I want to try 3-stage, using commercial motors and the techniques I developed for the two-stage version. I plan to re-use the booster, but build a new 4" dia 2nd booster and a 3" dia sustainer. With a pad weight of 110 lbs, RockSim predicts just a little under 100k ft, by flying long-burn motors (N to N to M, for 93% of full O impulse). The trajectory certainly won't be perfectly vertical, so I'm sure I'll lose a couple of miles off the altitude, but I should be able to double my current record, while staying in the same motor class.

 

Additional challenges: lighting up a sustainer motor at 35k ft (burst diaphragm), reducing rocket length (new ideas for avionics bays & recovery harness), 3rd-stage timing (smarter timer & pull-connector interlocks), optimum sustainer fin size (TBD), arming a 24-ft tall rocket on the pad (huge ladder?), launch pad (TBD, but if Jumbo were available?...) better tracking (GPS, plus recruiting some helpers stationed several miles downwind), video (light-weight on-board video camera, maybe some telemetry).

 

When? Who knows... Building what amounts to two high-perf rockets (incl one with video), in half a year is a stretch for me, cuz I don't get much rocket-building time these days. But my goal would be Sept'06 at XPRS. After that? Who knows? Big EX motor in a larger 1st booster, with spin-stabilized sustainer??  :-)

written by Adrian Carbine

 

 

 

 

 

  Home | What's New | Photos | Videos | Projects | Flight Data | Misc Info  | Links

 

 

 All photos not otherwise credited were taken by Vern Knowles

Vern Knowles © 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 All Rights Reserved